==+== Paper Review Form for CS 722a


==+== =====================================================================
==+== Reviewer: 
==-== Title: 
==-== Date: 


==+== =====================================================================
==+== Scoring (1-5)
==+==
==+== A. Overall merit:
==-==    Overall paper merit
==-== Choices: 1. Bottom 50% of submitted papers
==-==          2. Top 50% but not top 25% of submitted papers
==-==          3. Top 25% but not top 10% of submitted papers
==-==          4. Top 10% but not top 5% of submitted papers
==-==          5. Top 5% of submitted papers!
==-== Enter the number of your choice:


==+== B. Reviewer qualification
==-==    Your qualifications to review this paper
==-== Choices: 1. I know nothing about this area
==-==          2. I have passing familiarity
==-==          3. I know the material, but am not an expert
==-==          4. I know a lot about this area
==-==          5. I am an expert on this topic
==-== Enter the number of your choice:


==+== C. Novelty
==-== Choices: 1. Published before
==-==          2. Done before (not necessarily published)
==-==          3. Incremental improvement
==-==          4. New contribution
==-==          5. Surprisingly new contribution
==-== Enter the number of your choice:


==+== D. Paper summary
==-==    Please summarize this paper in your own words.


==+== E. Exciting
==-==    What is exciting about this paper?  Be brief, please.


==+== F. Boring
==-==    What is boring about this paper?  Be brief, please.


==+== G. Detailed comments
==-==    Specicific technical and/or presentation comments on the paper.


==+== End Review