Message-ID: <23609995.1075846709839.JavaMail.evans@thyme> Date: Fri, 16 Jun 2000 04:39:00 -0700 (PDT) From: marcel@turn.org To: tomb@crossborderenergy.com, bcherry@sempra.com, napedersen@jonesday.com Subject: Re: Final Late Exhibit Draft Cc: rmp@cpuc.ca.gov, bcherry@sempra.com, alexanms@sce.com, paulamirault@aec.ca, david.bayless@utility.com, burkee@cts.com, craigc@calpine.com, rick.counihan@greenmountain.com, jdasovic@enron.com, mday@gmssr.com, bdingwall@unitedgas.com, douglass@arterhadden.com, eke@aelaw.com, jfawcet@enron.com, rfoss@coral-energy.com, plg@cpuc.ca.gov, johnj@bcjlaw.com, johnson_pamela@lacoe.edu, karpjos@sf.whitecase.com, jleslie@luce.com, kmccrea@sablaw.com, jmpa@dynegy.com, porterdk@sce.com, rochmanm@cubjpa.org, rochmanm@spurr.org, susan.scott@enron.com, rbetonte@socalgas.com, tbrill@sempra.com, dfollett@sempra.com, jharrigan@socalgas.com, jhay@sempra.com, llorenz@socalgas.com, nmcvay@socalgas.com, rmorrow@socalgas.com, rpurves@sdge.com, wsakarias@sdge.com, lschavrien@sempra.com, gsullivan@sempra.com, tsurak@socalgas.com, jteeter@sdge.com, tp2jxv@socalgas.com, swatson@socalgas.com, gwright@sempra.com, dbarker@socalgas.com, lindseyhowdowning@dwt.com, chj@aelaw.com, bsl@cpuc.ca.gov, ack@aelaw.com, enelson@socalgas.com, jsuwara@sempra.com, wreed@sempra.com, napedersen@jonesday.com, ewo@jmbm.com, pjpowerlaw@aol.com, jaime.ramirez@swgas.com, larry.black@swgas.com, pfair@sdge.com, rch8@pge.com, exe3@pge.com, rrs5@pge.com, mcconnk@epenergy.com Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Bcc: rmp@cpuc.ca.gov, bcherry@sempra.com, alexanms@sce.com, paulamirault@aec.ca, david.bayless@utility.com, burkee@cts.com, craigc@calpine.com, rick.counihan@greenmountain.com, jdasovic@enron.com, mday@gmssr.com, bdingwall@unitedgas.com, douglass@arterhadden.com, eke@aelaw.com, jfawcet@enron.com, rfoss@coral-energy.com, plg@cpuc.ca.gov, johnj@bcjlaw.com, johnson_pamela@lacoe.edu, karpjos@sf.whitecase.com, jleslie@luce.com, kmccrea@sablaw.com, jmpa@dynegy.com, porterdk@sce.com, rochmanm@cubjpa.org, rochmanm@spurr.org, susan.scott@enron.com, rbetonte@socalgas.com, tbrill@sempra.com, dfollett@sempra.com, jharrigan@socalgas.com, jhay@sempra.com, llorenz@socalgas.com, nmcvay@socalgas.com, rmorrow@socalgas.com, rpurves@sdge.com, wsakarias@sdge.com, lschavrien@sempra.com, gsullivan@sempra.com, tsurak@socalgas.com, jteeter@sdge.com, tp2jxv@socalgas.com, swatson@socalgas.com, gwright@sempra.com, dbarker@socalgas.com, lindseyhowdowning@dwt.com, chj@aelaw.com, bsl@cpuc.ca.gov, ack@aelaw.com, enelson@socalgas.com, jsuwara@sempra.com, wreed@sempra.com, napedersen@jonesday.com, ewo@jmbm.com, pjpowerlaw@aol.com, jaime.ramirez@swgas.com, larry.black@swgas.com, pfair@sdge.com, rch8@pge.com, exe3@pge.com, rrs5@pge.com, mcconnk@epenergy.com X-From: Marcel Hawiger X-To: "Tom Beach" , "Cherry, Brian - TPBKC" , "Norman A. Pedersen" X-cc: "'Pocta, Robert M.'" , "Cherry, Brian - TPBKC" , , , , , , , , , , , , , , "'Gileau, Patrick L.'" , , , , , , , , , , , "Betonte, Robert - TP2RSB" , "Brill, Thomas R." , "Follett, B. David - TPDBF" , "Harrigan, James P. - TP1JPH" , "Hay, James E." , "Lorenz, Lad - TPLPL" , "McVay, Nancy W - TPNWM" , "Morrow, Rick - TP3RMM" , "Purves, Ralph A." , "Sakarias, Wayne P." , "Schavrien, Lee" , "Sullivan, Glen J." , "Surak, Thomas M. - TP1TMS" , "Teeter, James S." , "Van Lierop, Jan - TP2JXV" , "Watson, Steven - TP2SAW" , "Wright, Gillian - TP1GXW" , "Barker, David - TPDTB" , "'How-Downing, Lindsey'" , "'Jun, Christine'" , "'Khoury, Dexter'" , , "Nelson, Eric B. - TPEBN" , "Suwara, J.- TPJUS" , "Reed, William" , "'Pedersen, Norman'" , "'O'Neill, Ed'" , "'Power, Pat'" , "'Ramirez, Jaime'" , "'Black, Larry'" , "Fair, Pam" , "'Hall, Rich'" , "'Eisenman, Eric'" , "'Stoner, Ron'" , "'McConn, Kathy'" X-bcc: X-Folder: \Susan_Scott_Dec2000_June2001_1\Notes Folders\Gir X-Origin: SCOTT-S X-FileName: sscott3.nsf At 6/16/2000, Tom Beach wrote: >On behalf of Watson and Vernon, I strongly object to the removal of the data >on the takeaway capacity to other markets besides the SoCalGas system, as >Norman apparently proposes in his draft exhibit. Without the data on >takeaway capacity to other markets, the exhibit suggests that all of the >upstream interstate and PG&E capacity is designed to serve just the SoCalGas >market. The question is not what is designed to "serve" the SoCalGas market, but what is the upstream capacity flowing to SoCal's interconnection points that could theoretically serve SoCalGas if there was no limitation on SoCal's takeaway capacity. Based on this, Norman's exhibit seems OK unless there is some physical system constraint (besides SoCal's takeaway) that would limit potential inflow into the SoCalGas system. The problem with SoCal's last exhibit is that there is still no clarification of whether the upstream gas could flow into ANY ONE of the take away pipelines. Maybe this could be clarified somehow (in a footnote)? Marcel