Message-ID: <25775417.1075846714778.JavaMail.evans@thyme> Date: Mon, 11 Dec 2000 03:39:00 -0800 (PST) From: burkee@cts.com To: tomb@crossborderenergy.com, michael.alexander@sce.com, rochmanm@spurr.org Subject: Re: Proposed revisions to CSA Letter Cc: askaff@chrm.com, bdingwall@unitedgas.com, chj@aelaw.com, counihan@greenmountain.com, craigc@calpine.com, david.bayless@utility.com, eke@aelaw.com, gworster@txuenergy.com, jdasovic@enron.com, jeff.dasovich@enron.com, jfawcett@enron.com, jleslie@luce.com, dynegy@sce.com, johnson_pamela@lacoe.edu, karpjos@sf.whitecase.com, kmccrea@sablaw.com, kmills@cfbf.com, lindseyhowdowning@dwt.com, mday@gmssr.com, paulamirault@aec.ca, phildavies@aec.ca, porterdk@sce.com, rick.counihan@greenmountain.com, rmp@cpuc.ca.gov, rochmanm@spurr.org, sscott3@enron.com Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Bcc: askaff@chrm.com, bdingwall@unitedgas.com, chj@aelaw.com, counihan@greenmountain.com, craigc@calpine.com, david.bayless@utility.com, eke@aelaw.com, gworster@txuenergy.com, jdasovic@enron.com, jeff.dasovich@enron.com, jfawcett@enron.com, jleslie@luce.com, dynegy@sce.com, johnson_pamela@lacoe.edu, karpjos@sf.whitecase.com, kmccrea@sablaw.com, kmills@cfbf.com, lindseyhowdowning@dwt.com, mday@gmssr.com, paulamirault@aec.ca, phildavies@aec.ca, porterdk@sce.com, rick.counihan@greenmountain.com, rmp@cpuc.ca.gov, rochmanm@spurr.org, sscott3@enron.com X-From: "John Burkholder" X-To: "Tom Beach" , , "Michael Rochman" X-cc: "'Skaff, Andy@Dynegy'" , "'Dingwall, Brian@UEM'" , "'Jun, Christine@aelaw'" , "'Rick Counihan, Greenmountain.com'" , "'Craig Chancellor'" , "'Bayless, David@Utility'" , "'Elsesser, Evelyn@aelaw'" , "'Worster, Gerard@TXU'" , "'Jeff Dasovich'" , , "'Jeff Fawcett, Transwestern'" , , "'Paul, Joe@Dynegy'" , "'Johnson, Pamela@REMAC'" , "'Karp, Joseph@Whitecase'" , "'McCrea, Keith@CIG/CM'" , , "'How-Downing, Lindsey'" , "'MBD'" , "'Paul Amirault'" , "'Phil Davies, WGSI Calgary'" , "'Doug Porter'" , "'Counihan, Rick'" , "'Pocta, Robert M.'" , "Michael Rochman" , "'Scott, Susan@TW'" X-bcc: X-Folder: \Susan_Scott_Dec2000_June2001_1\Notes Folders\Notes inbox X-Origin: SCOTT-S X-FileName: sscott3.nsf You'll see that point in WHP's own comments as well, so we recommend it stay in as well. John BETA Consulting Burkee@cts.com (760) 723-1831 Voice (760) 723-1891 FAX ----- Original Message ----- From: Tom Beach To: ; Michael Rochman Cc: 'Skaff, Andy@Dynegy' ; 'Dingwall, Brian@UEM' ; 'John Burkholder' ; 'Jun, Christine@aelaw' ; 'Rick Counihan, Greenmountain.com' ; 'Craig Chancellor' ; 'Bayless, David@Utility' ; 'Elsesser, Evelyn@aelaw' ; 'Worster, Gerard@TXU' ; 'Jeff Dasovich' ; ; 'Jeff Fawcett, Transwestern' ; ; 'Paul, Joe@Dynegy' ; 'Johnson, Pamela@REMAC' ; 'Karp, Joseph@Whitecase' ; 'McCrea, Keith@CIG/CM' ; ; 'How-Downing, Lindsey' ; 'MBD' ; 'Paul Amirault' ; 'Phil Sent: Monday, December 11, 2000 11:34 AM Subject: Re: Proposed revisions to CSA Letter > I support putting back some more about how we have been jerked around > prcedurally. > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: > To: Michael Rochman > Cc: 'Mike Alexander' ; 'Skaff, Andy@Dynegy' > ; 'Dingwall, Brian@UEM' ; 'John > Burkholder' ; 'Jun, Christine@aelaw' ; 'Rick > Counihan, Greenmountain.com' ; 'Craig > Chancellor' ; 'Bayless, David@Utility' > ; 'Elsesser, Evelyn@aelaw' ; > 'Worster, Gerard@TXU' ; 'Jeff Dasovich' > ; ; 'Jeff Fawcett, > Transwestern' ; ; 'Paul, Joe@Dynegy' > ; 'Johnson, Pamela@REMAC' > ; 'Karp, Joseph@Whitecase' > ; 'McCrea, Keith@CIG/CM' ; > ; 'How-Downing, Lindsey' ; 'MBD' > ; 'Paul A > Sent: Monday, December 11, 2000 11:13 AM > Subject: RE: Proposed revisions to CSA Letter > > > > > > Mike, > > > > Edison can deal with the letter, either in it's pre-SoCalGas modified > form, > > or with the SoCalGas edited letter. Unless you hear otherwise from us, > > consider us signatories (using Doug Porter's name). > > > > However, I do agree with Michael Rochman that the SoCalGas version's > > comments on point five are a bit weaker than I would like. It is more > than > > a matter of having to duplicate the effort already expended, it is also a > > matter of having to justify that level of effort in light of a diminished > > perception (at least) of the chances of implementation of the results of > > that effort. I would prefer that be indicated politely, but clearly. > > > > > > -- > > Michael S. Alexander > > Southern California Edison > > 626-302-2029 > > 626-302-3254 (fax) > > > > > > > > > > Michael > > Rochman To: "'MBD'" , > "'Pocta, Robert > > , > "'Counihan, Rick'" > > rr.org> > , > > "'Jeff.Dasovich@enron.com'" > > 12/11/2000 , "'John > Burkholder'" > > 10:57 AM , "'Mike > Alexander'" > > , "'Craig > Chancellor'" > > , "'Colin > Cushnie'" > > , "'Jeff > Dasovich'" > > , "'Paul > Amirault'" > > , "'Doug > Porter'" > > , "'Tom Beach'" > > , > "'Amirault, Paul'" > > , "'Craig > Chancellor, > > Calpine'" , > "'How-Downing, > > Lindsey'" > , "'Phil > > Davies, WGSI Calgary'" > , > > "'jleslie@LUCE.com'" > , "'Jeff > > Fawcett, Transwestern'" > , > > Michael Rochman > , "'Rick > > Counihan, Greenmountain.com'" > > , > "'Bayless, > > David@Utility'" > , > > "'Dingwall, Brian@UEM'" > , > > "'Elsesser, Evelyn@aelaw'" > , > > "'Johnson, Pamela@REMAC'" > > , > "'Jun, > > Christine@aelaw'" > , "'Karp, > > Joseph@Whitecase'" > , > > "'McCrea, Keith@CIG/CM'" > , > > "'Paul, Joe@Dynegy'" > , "'Pocta, > > Mark@ORA'" , > "'Scott, Susan@TW'" > > , "'Worster, > Gerard@TXU'" > > , > "'kmills@CFBF.com'" > > , "'Karp, > Joseph@Whitecase'" > > , > "'Skaff, Andy@Dynegy'" > > > > cc: > > Subject: RE: Proposed > revisions to CSA Letter > > > > > > > > > > > > I would like to see us try to re-insert words to the effect that if the > > Commission throws out the CSA after haranguing the parties to reach an > > agreement, it will seriously discourage future settlement efforts by > > parties. That is not a deal-breaker for me, just a suggestion. Otherwise > > the comments are fine. > > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: MBD [mailto:MDay@GMSSR.com] > > Sent: Monday, December 11, 2000 10:43 AM > > To: 'Pocta, Robert M.'; 'Counihan, Rick'; 'Jeff.Dasovich@enron.com'; > > 'John Burkholder'; 'Mike Alexander'; 'Craig Chancellor'; 'Colin > > Cushnie'; 'Jeff Dasovich'; MBD; 'Paul Amirault'; 'Doug Porter'; 'Tom > > Beach'; 'Amirault, Paul'; 'Craig Chancellor, Calpine'; 'How-Downing, > > Lindsey'; 'Phil Davies, WGSI Calgary'; 'jleslie@LUCE.com'; 'Jeff > > Fawcett, Transwestern'; 'Michael Rochman'; 'Rick Counihan, > > Greenmountain.com'; 'Bayless, David@Utility'; 'Dingwall, Brian@UEM'; > > 'Elsesser, Evelyn@aelaw'; 'Johnson, Pamela@REMAC'; 'Jun, > > Christine@aelaw'; 'Karp, Joseph@Whitecase'; 'McCrea, Keith@CIG/CM'; > > 'Paul, Joe@Dynegy'; 'Pocta, Mark@ORA'; 'Scott, Susan@TW'; 'Worster, > > Gerard@TXU'; 'kmills@CFBF.com'; 'Karp, Joseph@Whitecase'; 'Skaff, > > Andy@Dynegy' > > Subject: FW: Proposed revisions to CSA Letter > > > > > > > > > > > > Here are some edits to our letter from socal. I do not feel they diminsh > > the usefulness of the letter, and they moderate the tone a little, as you > > would expect. They also eliminate the lengthy recitation of the > procedural > > > > events at the end of the letter. If this gets them on the letter, I say > > let's sign. I will assume everyone who signed on last week stays on the > > letter unless I hear differently from you by 3 pm today. I really > > appreciate the quick turnaround. Mike Day > > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Wright, Gillian - TP1GXW [mailto:GWright@sempra.com] > > Sent: Monday, December 11, 2000 10:26 AM > > To: 'mday@gmssr.com' > > Subject: Proposed revisions to CSA Letter > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Mike, > > Here are SoCal's proposed revisions to the CSA letter - I'll call in a > > minute. The edits are pretty extensive, but all along the lines we > > discussed (ie changing the tone to a more positive one). > > > > > > Gillian > > > > > > <> > > > > > > Gillian A. Wright > > Regulatory Case Manager > > Sempra Energy > > 555 W. Fifth St. GT14D6 > > Los Angeles, CA 90013-1011 > > (213) 244-3833 > > (213) 244-8820 fax > > gwright@sempra.com > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >